For eyes, I love Make Up For Aqua Cream. When you apply the color, just apply a swish of product to your lid. Don't go above the crease. This keeps your look interesting, not overwhelming. If you want to keep it really subtle, line your eyes with a pop of color in Aqua Cream. But there are exceptions. If your eyes are green, use purple. If your eyes are brown, use green. If your eyes are blue, use navy.
Illuminate your skin. Use your favorite beauty balm and possibly a skin brightener so the focus is on your new look. There are no distractions when you appear to have perfect skin, and with the products out today, that's an easy one to fake.